7 Best Dog Subscription Boxes of 2024
by Nicole Pajer
Published on March 04, 2022
We all want the best for our pets and that might include a bit of spoiling. A monthly dog subscription box is a great way to give your pup some extra love!
In recent years, subscriptions have gotten more and more popular due to convenience and cost savings. We subscribe to everything from meals to household items to streaming services, so why not something for our four-legged friends?
With a subscription dog box full of new treats, toys, and pup-friendly accessories, you and your dog will enjoy a new adventure every month!
Our Picks
- Best Overall Dog Subscription Box: BarkBox
- Best Dog Subscription Box for Heavy Chewers: BullyMake
- Best Dog Toy Subscription Box: PupBox
- Most Customizable Dog Subscription Box: PupJoy
- Best Dog Clothing Subscription Box: The Dapper Dog Box
- Best Dog Mom Subscription Box: Pup Mom Crate
- Best Dog Treat Subscription Box: Real Dog Box
What is a Dog Subscription Box?
Dog subscription boxes are a convenient way to get treats, chews, toys, apparel, and fun surprises delivered directly to your home. And a monthly subscription box for dogs reduces trips to the pet store or the need to order all these items separately, saving you time and money.
Many subscription-based companies offer handmade treats from local bakeries, fresh dog food, and non-toxic toys that are safe for your four-legged friend. Themed dog boxes are also popular, including holiday, birthday, puppy, etc.
Monthly dog subscription boxes are a great way to keep your pooch healthy, happy, and pampered without breaking the bank. But be sure to compare the different offerings to ensure you get the right one for your pet.
Dog Subscription Boxes: The Pros and Cons
There are pros and cons to a monthly dog box.
Pros:
- New toys and treats to keep your dog happy and stimulated.
- Fun themes (great for pet pics)!
- Introduction to new toys, treats, food and chews.
- Ability to test and try a variety of items.
- Cheaper and more convenient than buying all the items separately.
Cons:
- Toys start to accumulate quickly and may cause clutter.
- You may not use all of the items in the box.
- Some pets may lose interest in their food when fed too many treats.
- Monthly subscription costs can start to add up if you’re not paying attention to them.
7 Best Dog Subscription Boxes
Now that you know what they are, let’s compare our picks for the best dog subscription boxes. Here are a few of the different types, which include everything from dog subscription boxes for heavy chewers to dog treat subscription boxes, and more!
Best Overall Dog Subscription Box
Our Pick: BarkBox
Cost: $30/box with a 12-month subscription.
When it comes to monthly subscription boxes for dogs, BarkBox is our overall favorite. Every month there’s a surprise theme such as “Sweetie Pies Barkery” for February and “Lick or Treat” for October. The boxes include two adorable high-quality toys, two all-natural bags of treats, and a chew, all curated for the theme making each month a new adventure!
Highlights
- Every dog box includes over $40 worth of toys and treats.
- Free “double first box” promo upon signing up for a monthly subscription.
- Customizable monthly subscription boxes, including a “Super Chewer” optional upgrade, which makes this a great dog subscription box for heavy chewers.
Things to Consider
- It’s more expensive ($35-$45/box) if you don’t commit to a year subscription.
Best Dog Subscription Box for Heavy Chewers
Our Pick: BullyMake
Cost: $31/box with a 12-month subscription.
If your pup is a power chewer, you’ll want a subscription box with durable dog toys. BullyMake’s custom designed toys are made of nylon, rubber, rope, and ballistic material, made for heavy chewers. Monthly BullyMake dog subscription boxes include 2-3 tough toys and 3 bags of treats.
Highlights
- High-quality chew toys and treats, made in the USA.
- Customizable monthly dog boxes.
- Over $50 worth of toys and treats in every box.
Things to Consider
- No “plush” toys included. Boxes feature all durable chew toys.
- The toys may be too tough for some dogs.
Best Dog Toy Subscription Box
Our Pick: PupBox
Cost: $29/box with a 12-month subscription.
Our top dog toy subscription box is PupBox. This is great for all dogs who love to play with toys, especially puppies! Monthly boxes include treats, chews, and a wide variety of toys and fun accessories like collars, birthday hats, and cleaning/grooming accessories.
Highlights
- Dog subscription boxes are catered to the dog’s age.
Things to Consider
- Chew toys are usually plush, not durable enough for a heavy chewer.
- It’s more expensive ($32-$39/box) if you don’t commit to a year subscription.
Most Customizable Dog Subscription Box
Our Pick: PupJoy
Cost: Dog boxes range from $29.99 – $54.99 depending on the type of box you choose. There is a discount for VIP members.
If you want a flexible and customizable dog subscription box, PupJoy is a great option. You can choose from their monthly curated boxes or you can build your own delivery and customize the products in your boxes. Dog boxes come packed with high quality, USA-made treats and fun toys. There’s also a power-chewer option for heavy chewers. PupJoy also offers boxes for one-time purchase so you can test them out or purchase one as a gift.
Highlights
- Customizable with many different products to choose from.
- We like that you can set your own delivery schedule and product categories.
- One-time customizable gift boxes available.
- Products featured are sustainable and good for the planet.
Things to Consider
- Some of the options are more expensive than most other dog subscription boxes.
Best Dog Clothing Subscription Box
Our Pick: The Dapper Dog Box
Cost: $24.15 for the first box, renews at $35/box.
If your dog likes to get attention as well as treats, this is the perfect dog subscription box. Each box includes two treats or chews, two toys, and an adorable limited edition dog bandana. Your pup will be the fashionable envy of the neighborhood!
Highlights
- Fun themes, such as Birthday Party, Fiesta, and Happy Howlidays.
- High quality treats made in the USA from family farms and local bakeries.
- A portion of all sales is donated to help rescue and shelter dogs.
Things to Consider:
- Designed for large to extra large dogs (36 +lbs).
- More expensive than most other dog subscription boxes.
Best Dog Mom Subscription Box
Our Pick: Pup Mom Crate
Cost: $39.99 per monthly box.
Are you a dog mommy? Pup Mom Crate offers a dog mom subscription dog box curated specially for the dog mom and her pet. Boxes include 5-8 fun themed goodies and accessories such as dog toys and treats for the pet and fun lifestyle items and cosmetics for the mom.
Highlights
- Creative and fun themes and items.
- Boxes are bigger and include more than other companies.
- Fun for pets and pet parents!
Things to Consider
- More expensive than most other dog subscription boxes.
- You may not use or already have some of the items included in the box.
Best Dog Treat Subscription Box
Our Pick: Real Dog Box
Cost: Boxes start at $19 per month.
If you have all the toys and accessories you need and are just looking for a dog treat subscription box, Real Dog Box is our top pick. This is a great choice if you are a dog trainer or you have a puppy in training where you need a lot of high-quality treats. They offer four different boxes containing a variety of all natural, unprocessed treats and chews without any chemicals or fillers.
Highlights
- Great way to sample new treats and chews.
- Real, high-quality food, mostly human-grade and made in California.
- Perfect for a picky eater who gets tired of the same treats.
- Month-to-month subscription, easy to cancel or skip a month.
Things to Consider
- More expensive than other treat boxes due to the higher quality ingredients.
Compare Dog Subscription Boxes
If you’re trying to figure out which is the best dog subscription box for your canine companion, use this chart to compare dog subscription box features, prices, shipping rates, and more.
| BarkBox | BullyMake | PupBox | PupJoy | The Dapper Dog | Pup Mom Crate | Real Dog Box | |
| Products | Toys, treats, chews, fun themes | Tough chew toys, treats | Toys, training tips, accessories, chews and treats | Sustainable toys, treats, and chews | Toys, treats, bandana | Toys, treats, lifestyle items, cosmetics | Treats, chews |
| Sizes Available | Small, Medium, Large | One Size | One size. Choose life stage. | Small/Medium or Large/X-Large | Extra Small, Small/Medium, Large/X-Large | Small, Medium, Large | One size. Different types available. |
| Number of Products | Varies | 3 treats, 2-3 toys | Varies | Varies | 5 | 5-8 | 3-6 |
| Frequency | Monthly | Monthly | Monthly | Monthly. One-time purchase available. | Monthly | Monthly | Monthly |
| Price | $30-$45 | $31-$45 | $29-$39 | $29.99 – $54.99 | $30-$35.99 | $36-$39.99 | $19-$37 |
| Price Tiers | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | No |
| Free Shipping | Yes | Yes | Yes | For VIP Members | Yes | Yes | For Members |
| Customizable | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | No | Yes |
| For Heavy Chewers | Yes | Yes | No | Yes | Yes | No | Yes |
| Includes People Products | No | No | No | No | No | Yes | No |
| Give-Back Program | No | No | No | Yes | No | No | No |
| Money-Back Guarantee | Yes | No, but they offer a toy-replacement program | No | Yes | No | Yes | Yes |
Dog Subscription Box Costs
You can expect to pay $25-$40/box for a monthly dog subscription box. The prices range based on the amount of toys, treats, and accessories that are included. The higher quality treats and more durable chew toys will also be more expensive.
Most of the companies have different dog box subscription plans with one-time purchases being the most expensive, 3 or 6 month plans for a small discount, and a 1-year (paid up front) being the best overall deal.
Tips for Choosing the Best Dog Subscription Box
Choosing the right dog subscription box is important so you can get the most out of every shipment, especially if you plan to pay for a year-long subscription. Here are some things to consider when shopping for a monthly dog box.
Consider your pet’s age, size, diet, energy level, and interests. While most monthly subscription boxes for dogs will cater to a variety of ages and interests, it’s important to think about your dog’s likes, dislikes, and specific needs. If you have a puppy, you may want to look for a dog box that is specifically geared towards young dogs. If you have a dog that needs to lose weight (per your vet’s recommendation), a monthly treat box may not be the best idea!
Keep your dog’s chew strength in mind. Most of these dog boxes come with a fun variety of toys. But not all toys are designed for heavy chewers. If your dog destroys plush toys, look for a dog subscription box that offers heavy-duty dog toys.
Think about your budget. Monthly dog subscription boxes can easily become expensive—especially if you have multiple subscriptions. And the last thing you want to do is pay for items that your dog doesn’t enjoy or use. Make sure to compare costs, read fine print, and choose a dog box that fits your budget and your dog’s needs.
